Why Melbourne Property Has Under-Performed

Melbourne has long been one of Australia’s most resilient property markets, consistently delivering strong returns for investors. However, in the most recent years, this trend has shifted, with Melbourne’s property market underperforming compared to other major cities. For Australian expats who have always seen Melbourne as a safe bet for property investment, this shift raises important questions.

Why has Melbourne, a city known for its vibrant culture and robust economy, struggled so much? Let’s dive into the key reasons behind this downturn and what it could mean for you.

Economic Challenges

One of the primary reasons behind Melbourne's recent property market struggles is the broader economic challenges facing Victoria. Over the past few years, the state has experienced a significant economic downturn, marked by a reduction in the number of businesses operating in the region. According to the latest data, Victoria saw a net loss of businesses in the 2022-23 financial year, which contrasts sharply with states like Queensland that have seen business growth.

This economic contraction has had a direct impact on consumer confidence and, by extension, the property market. When businesses close and job opportunities diminish, people become more cautious about making significant financial commitments, such as purchasing property. This hesitation is reflected in Melbourne’s stagnant property prices, which have struggled to keep pace with other Australian cities.

The lockdowns and the reduced numbers of international students also hit the inner city areas of Melbourne quite hard. With international students representing a high portion of tenants in many of these inner suburbs, it made it tough for both landlords and businesses in these communities.

Long-Term Impact of Lockdowns

Melbourne endured some of the longest and strictest lockdowns in the world during the COVID-19 pandemic. While these measures were necessary to control the spread of the virus, they have had lasting effects on the local economy. The extended lockdowns took a heavy toll on small businesses, particularly in the hospitality and retail sectors, with many unable to recover and forced to close their doors permanently.

For Australian expats considering investment in Melbourne, this is a crucial factor to consider. The once-thriving areas that attracted residents and investors alike have seen a decline in activity and vibrancy. The knock-on effect has been a reduction in property demand, as the appeal of these areas has diminished. Without the bustling local economy to support them, property values in these regions have struggled to recover.

Increased Tax Burden on Property Investors

One of the significant factors contributing to Melbourne’s recent property market struggles is the increased tax burden on property investors. In response to the economic challenges following the pandemic, the Victorian government has introduced a series of tax measures that have placed additional financial pressure on investors.

Key among these changes are increases in stamp duty and land tax. The Victorian government has raised the land tax rates for properties above certain value thresholds, making it more expensive for investors to hold onto their properties. Additionally, stamp duty surcharges for foreign buyers and absentee owners have further increased the costs associated with property investment in the state.

These tax hikes have made Melbourne a less attractive market for property investors, particularly when compared to other states where the tax environment is more favourable. The higher holding costs and transaction expenses in Victoria have led some investors to look elsewhere for opportunities, contributing to the softening demand in Melbourne’s property market.

For investors, these tax changes represent more than just an additional financial burden—they signal a challenging investment environment where profit margins are increasingly squeezed. This has led to a growing exodus of property investors from Melbourne, as they seek markets with lower taxes and more predictable regulatory frameworks.

Property Investor Disillusionment

For many years, Melbourne was seen as a solid choice for property investors, offering steady returns and a stable market. However, recent changes in Victoria's residential tenancy laws have caused a shift in investor sentiment. These reforms, designed to protect tenants, have introduced stricter regulations that make it more challenging for landlords to manage their properties.

Among the changes are mandatory minimum standards for rental properties, more stringent eviction rules, and additional obligations for landlords. While these measures have been beneficial for tenants, they’ve increased the costs and administrative burdens for property owners. Many investors now feel that the balance has tipped too far in favour of tenants, making property investment less attractive in Melbourne compared to other states.

As a result, there has been a noticeable exodus of property investors from Melbourne. Despite rising rental yields, many investors are seeking more favourable conditions in other states, where the regulatory and tax environments are perceived as more investor-friendly. However, it's important to note that other states are also tightening their tenancy laws and adjusting land tax rules, so the grass may not be greener elsewhere.

Is There an Opportunity for Investors?

Despite the current challenges, Melbourne’s property market may present a unique opportunity for savvy investors. With property prices in some areas now sitting below replacement costs, there’s potential for significant gains as the market recovers.

This situation is reminiscent of the downturns experienced in Brisbane and Perth a few years ago. During those times, properties in those cities were undervalued, but those who bought during the downturn saw substantial capital growth as the markets recovered. Melbourne could be on a similar trajectory, with the potential for strong returns once the economic conditions improve.

Investors who can look past the current difficulties and focus on long-term growth may find themselves in a favourable position. The key is to identify undervalued properties in areas poised for recovery and to have the patience to ride out the current market challenges.

The Path to Recovery

Looking ahead, many experts believe that Melbourne’s property market is primed for a comeback. Improved affordability and rising rental yields are likely to attract both investors and homebuyers back to the market, especially as the broader economic conditions stabilise.

AMP chief economist Shane Oliver has suggested that Melbourne’s extended period of underperformance could set the stage for a robust rebound. He predicts that, while it may take a few rate cuts to reignite Melbourne’s property market, the recovery could be stronger than in other capitals like Brisbane and Adelaide, depending on broader economic factors.

As interest rates eventually fall and the economy begins to recover, Melbourne’s property market is expected to follow suit. Investors who position themselves now could benefit from both capital growth and improved rental returns as the market catches up to its historical performance levels.

Conclusion

Melbourne’s property market has certainly faced its share of challenges in recent years, from economic headwinds and the lingering effects of lockdowns to increased tax burdens and stricter tenancy laws. However, these challenges have also created a potential window of opportunity for investors who are willing to take a long-term view.

While the Victorian government will need to address its economic issues without placing further strain on businesses and property owners, the current state of the market offers a chance to buy properties below replacement cost. As the market recovers, these investments could yield substantial returns, making now an opportune time for those looking to capitalise on Melbourne’s future growth.

For Australian expats and other potential investors, the key takeaway is to stay informed and strategic. Melbourne’s property market may be down, but it’s far from out, and those who act wisely could reap significant rewards as the city regains its strength. 

Embark on your property investment journey with Ally Property Group, your trusted ally in Australia's real estate market. Our expert advisers are dedicated to crafting personalised investment strategies for Australian expats and residents alike, aiming to enhance your portfolio and maximise returns. Start building your wealth with Ally Property Group, where strategic insights, analysis and modelling leads to prosperous investments.

We’re more than just property advisers. As Australian expats ourselves, we've navigated the intricate world of property investment both at home and abroad. With a legacy rooted in financial services, we offer a holistic, transparent, and strategic approach, ensuring you're equipped with the knowledge and confidence to make informed decisions.

Book an obligation-free, complimentary consultation here today.

General Information Warning: The information contained herein is of a general nature only and does not constitute in any way, personal advice. You should not act on any recommendation without considering your personal needs, circumstances, and objectives. We recommend you obtain professional property investment advice specific to your circumstances.